Paesano's Pizzeria Information

Tucked into the heart of Staten Island at 12 Bradley Ave, Paesano's Pizzeria is the kind of spot that immediately makes you feel at home, whether you’re a neighborhood regular or just passing through. The moment you step inside, the aroma of freshly baked pizza mingling with garlic and herbs sets the tone for a casual, comforting dining experience. The menu is classic yet thoughtfully curated, featuring hand-tossed pizzas with perfectly crisp crusts and toppings that taste fresh and generous, from savory pepperoni to creamy mozzarella with basil. Beyond pizza, the pasta selections are a pleasant surprise, hearty and rich without being overwhelming, and the subs and calzones make for satisfying alternatives if you’re craving something different. Service here has earned its share of praise, with staff who are attentive and friendly, often remembering regulars’ preferences, and despite busy weekends, the wait is usually manageable, reflecting a well-organized kitchen and a team that keeps things moving smoothly. The interior carries a welcoming, no-frills vibe, accented by cozy booths and casual seating that makes it ideal for families or a relaxed meal with friends, and it’s easy to imagine local kids stopping by for a quick slice after school. Reviews frequently highlight the balance of quality and value-generous portions without a hefty price tag-which keeps both locals and visitors coming back. While the pizzeria is comfortable for dining in, takeout is equally convenient, especially if you’re in the mood for a movie night at home or a picnic at a nearby park. From the crispness of the crust to the warmth of the staff and the inviting atmosphere, Paesano's Pizzeria delivers a classic Italian-American experience that feels both authentic and accessible, making it a standout choice on Staten Island’s pizza scene.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

Tiny pizza spot with an awful parking lot, but don't worry, it does get better from here. Hadn't heard much about this spot, but I had to try it as part of my mission to have all the pizza on Staten Island. The box boasted that they were among Staten Island's best thin and crispy pizzas. I was skeptical. Then I was pleasantly surprised. Hidden gem right here! Sauce was tasty. The bottom of the pie had a unique crunch. Good crust. Surprising amount of flop, but it didn't hurt it. Could be we arrived too early. They were just getting started. I give it an 8.1.

This small pizzeria has Outstanding Food with very reasonable prices. Have ordered numerous times and never disappointed. Ordered last night Chicken Francese which came with pasta and order of garlic knots that was delicious. Portions are generous for the price. Paesano's is a local Gem!

Ordered a LG cheese pie for delivery & it arrived within 47 minutes. Pretty, pretty pretty GOOD. The driver was a man of few words, but lovely.. The pizza crust was delicious, the sauce was a little bland & the cheese was hard to find. I expected a gooey, NY style pie and received a decent one for a decent price. Next time I order, extra cheese is a MUST.

Wow ! Shoutout to Carlos (lol I don’t know him) but I had to call and ask if the woman made them herself and she said he made the garlic knots.. freshly made wow .. the pizza was delicious as well.. yum def 5 ⭐

Tried the Vodka pie and it’s delicious. Much less cheese and vodka sauce is great. Same delicious crunchy dough.

The food is absolutely delicious ! The price is excellent ! The best garlic knots , vodka sauce and substantial food ! I order every week and it just gets better ! Hidden gem !

Best pizzeria on the north shore. The pizza is always cooked perfectly. Their rolls are huge & delicious. Their wraps & hero’s are also amazing. Everything is reasonably priced for the amount & quality of food you are getting. We’ve ordered from here numerous times and never every time it has been perfect. It’s our go to pizzeria! We order through Slice & someone from Paesanos always calls us shortly after to verify our order, which is nice. The delivery man is also the best, so friendly and, always on time. The food is still hot on delivery.

This place was amazing. The food is very good and relatively cheap, if you are in New York and plan on visiting Little Italy, I highly recommend this place. The staff is very nice and the service is amazing. You could get any of the food and I can say that you will have a fantastic experience. The food is just absolutely breathtaking and amazing.

Paesano's Pizzeria